Guest Lecturer
We are stuck in a period of ordinary politics when we need to be transformed into a period of extraordinary politics and bold leadership to address the important issues of the day, including national issues such as global terrorism and energy independence to local issues such as traffic congestion. At the state and national levels we have bipartisan paralysis; condescending Democrats/liberals and sanctimonious Republicans/conservatives content to call each other names and fix blame but not willing to come together to solve problems. The paralysis benefits the Democrats because the Republicans are the majority party. In Virginia, the Republican led House and Senate can’t seem to work with each other. Republicans are bogged down on taxes, marriage and guns. While these issues play well with the Republican base, they turn off the vast majority of non-movement conservatives. Republican ascendance to power in Virginia has ebbed. The quality of our stewardship of the State and national governments is being questioned. We have little influence at the local level in Fairfax.
In Fairfax, Republicans are out of sync with the needs, wants and moods of the majority of voters. We received 38%.of the vote last November. As the party activists become more conservative and our candidates become more ideologically rigid, moderate Republican and independent voters either stay home or vote Democrat. It is also argued that conservative voters stay home because they are disillusioned Our vote totals and our volunteer numbers are declining rapidly. Last year, the most conservative Republican candidates were defeated by the largest margins. Our statewide candidates lost all magisterial districts. In Braddock District, Kilgore lost all precincts, Bolling won one precinct and McDonnell won three precincts. Our Delegate candidates lost all precincts except one.
Many of our leaders ignore these facts. It has been said that the problem with ideology is that it “edits reality and paralyzes thought”. Our conservative ideologues argue that we lost because our candidates were not conservative enough or they blame the down ticket losses on Kilgore and President Bush. Their solution is to get rid of the RINOs—Republicans with whom they don’t agree. Some extreme ideologues have taken to attacking Republican elected officials like Senator Devolites –Davis and others in the Press. These individuals give all Republicans a bad name. They should be repudiated! To those who hold such views, I say it is time to touch base with reality. The reality that counts is that which is in the minds of the voters. Those who justify their intransigence on the basis of their strict adherence to “conservative principles” need to realize that political success is the result of understanding what the voters need/want and finding ways to provide it to them. Purging the party of non-true-believers, staying home or forming another political party is a recipe for failure.
Conservatives assume that the Republican Party is conservative. But the Party of Lincoln has stood for many things at different times; from abolition of slavery to environmentalism under Teddy Roosevelt and anti-communism. The Republican Party and conservatism must now be self-corrected by prudence, reality and the need to relate better to the voters. Our issues need reframing and our candidates need to be of higher quality. The voters told us we have image, message, candidate and organization problems.
For our government and political parties to work, a stable consensus is required, not power and domination by an ideological elite. Our party must produce candidates who can gain broad based support from an increasingly diverse electorate. These candidates must be articulate and offer real solutions to our priority problems. We can’t continue to place ideology over competence and ignore the views of the majority of the voters. The only conclusion that should be drawn from our recent experience is that moderate and more extreme Republicans and conservatives need each other and that which divides them needs to be resolved or at least the issue positions that are taken need to be reframed to accommodate a much broader group of supporters. If the party continues to move to the right in a battle for intra-party control and power, it will only continue to lose elections and the ability to influence public policy. Our leverage is in the future not the past. The party with a strong vision for the future and sound ideas will form a majority and hold it until they lose control of that vision and stop offering solid problem-solving ideas. I believe that Republicans are in danger of losing their vision, their ideas and their control.
Larry Krakover
